skip to main contentskip to popular page linksskip to main navigation links
photo of Mike Capuano Michael E. Capuano representing the 7th district of Massachusetts in the U.S. House of Representatives Go to the House of Representatives homepage
Like Mike on Facebook Visit Mike's video channel on YouTube Like Mike on Facebook


 My Schedule My Voting Record District Maps Register To Vote FAQ Site Map e-Updates

12,456 subscribers
Print Version-Trump’s judge pick fatally flawed


Trump’s judge pick fatally flawed

by Rep. Michael Capuano (MA-07) | Read it on

March 17, 2018

The day many of us feared when Donald Trump was elected president arrived July 9. He has nominated Judge Brett Kavanaugh to serve on the Supreme Court. If confirmed by the Senate, Judge Kavanaugh will be in a position to reshape the direction of our country for generations. Sure, Judge Kavanaugh should get a fair hearing, but everything I know about his record leads me to conclude he is a bad choice for our country — one that needs to be vigorously fought. I may not have a vote in the Senate but I have an obligation to raise my voice on behalf of my constituents to speak out against this terrible nominee. Why is this nomination so concerning? Too many ways to count.

Name an issue you care about and it is at risk with this nomination. The Trump administration won’t defend the Affordable Care Act in court anymore even though it is the responsibility of the Department of Justice to defend federal laws. There is a good chance this case, which challenges many of the protections of the ACA, will make it to the Supreme Court and access to health care in this country will be in serious jeopardy. If you have a pre-existing condition like asthma, high blood pressure or a past cancer diagnosis, you should be worried.

If you support reproductive freedom and believe that Roe v. Wade is settled law, you should be very concerned. Candidate Trump promised he would only nominate judges who would overturn Roe v. Wade. We know Judge Kavanaugh voted to deny an immigrant in ICE custody access to an abortion. That gives us much more than a hint about how he views women’s rights in these matters.

Civil rights, voting rights, LGBTQ­ rights, the right to privacy and so many victories won with so much struggle in past decades are at stake with this nomination. We have made too much important progress on these issues to turn back now.

Judge Kavanaugh’s deep political ties concern me too. He was the main author of the Starr report on President Clinton and deeply involved in efforts to stop the 2000 Florida recount. In 2009, Judge Kavanaugh opined that a sitting president shouldn’t be subject to indictment because it would pose too much of a distraction from governing and moreover, shouldn’t even have to answer questions from law enforcement. That must have been music to Trump’s ears. His nominee to the highest court in the land thinks it’s the indictment of Trump that would be the distraction. Kavanaugh has predetermined that a valid indictment should go nowhere regardless of what illegal acts an indictment might uncover. That’s astonishing. The buck stops at the Supreme Court. If Trump gets to choose someone who has already decided he shouldn’t be indicted or subject to questioning, isn’t that as good as saying Trump is above the law?

The Supreme Court will almost certainly have a role in deciding at least some of the issues concerning the Trump family’s ethics violations and conflicts of interest and issues involving Russian interference in our elections. Given that reality, and for all the reasons laid out, this nominee should not be confirmed.


12,456 subscribers





Home | About | Biography | Contact | Issues | Links | News | Schedules | Services

E-Updates | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Accessibility

110 First Street
Cambridge, MA 02141
P: (617) 621-6208
F: (617) 621-8628

  Constituent Services Click to close menu
  Casework and Assistance
  Immigration Casework
  Grants and Federal Domestic Assistance
  Presidential Greetings
  Washington, D.C. Attractions
  U.S. Service Academy Nominations
  Media Center Click to close menu
  Press Items
  Recent Votes
  Video and Audio
  Legislative Work Click to close menu
  Recent Votes
  Voting Record
  Sponsored Legislation
  Earmark Requests
  Committees and Caucuses
  Ethics Task Force
  Schedules Click to close menu
  My Schedule
  House Floor Summary
  Weekly House Schedule
  Annual House Calendar
  Weekly Senate Schedule
  Our District Click to close menu
  The 7th District Over the Years
  Nobel Prize Winners
  Interesting facts about Massachusetts
  Massachusetts Links
  Links Click to close menu
  Massachusetts Links
    State Government
    About the 7th District
    Arts, Culture and Attractions
    Chambers of Commerce
    Colleges and Universities
    Exploring Massachusetts
    Hospitals and Health Organizations

  Federal Government Links - Official Government Portal
    Legislative Branch
    Executive Branch
    Judicial Branch
    Federal Agencies
    Kids' Pages
    Register to Vote
    Washington, D.C. Attractions
    Business Opportunities with the Government
  Contact Click to close menu
  District Office
  Washington, D.C. Office
  Office Hours Program
  Community Meetings
  E-mail Me